Rev. Dr. L. Rumble, M.S.C.
of Radio Replies
Australian Catholic Truth Society (1951). No. 1136
* * *
I know the thought that the title of this little book will at once
bring to your mind. You will think of the broken families, murdered
people, and displaced persons transported to only God knows where by
ruthless tyrants in Communist-occupied countries. And there would be
good grounds of your thinking in such a way. For the number of missing
Catholics in that sense of the word is almost beyond human calculation.
[This was especially true in 1951, but it is sadly still true of such
places as China, North Korea, Vietnam and Cuba. A tyranny of a
different flavour, militant Islamism, produces the same result in such
places as Sudan today.]
All the same, this booklet is not concerned with the tragedy that has
over-taken them. It is concerned with the Catholics who are missing in
our own country. And that, too, is tragedy both for the Church and for
the victims of the prevalent atmosphere - almost the epidemic - of
Again and again it has been noticed that, in response to a compulsory
census, whether civic or military, ever so many people will put
themselves down as Catholics who are missing from the statistical
returns compiled by Church officials. And there is little room for
doubt that the majority of these missing Catholics are missing Mass,
missing their prayers, missing a host of blessings and consolation
which they try to persuade themselves they don't miss at all in this
life; and they seldom advert to their danger of missing all prospects
of eternal happiness in the next life.
Now if you, who happen to be reading this booklet, are one of the
missing ones, it is to you that I wish particularly to speak. I want to
remind you of things you have too easily forgotten; or to which,
perhaps, you have never given any real thought at all. For if you are a
''should-be" Catholic, there is a glorious inheritance which is
rightfully yours, even though at present you do not claim it. It has
obligations, of course, as well as privileges; and maybe you feel a
sense of relief from the obligations in waiving your claim to the
privileges But in reality the privileges far outweigh the obligations,
and you are missing far more than you realize in just letting yourself
That is easily said, I know. But we'll see more about that as we go
along. For the moment, let us begin where everything began for you in
this particular matter. If you describe yourself as a Catholic, it is
because you were at least baptized or christened a Catholic. That means
that you can never really cease to be a Catholic. For baptism is an
indelible and irrevocable action which cannot be undone. It literally
marks one off, sets one aside, branding the very soul as the property
of Jesus Christ and a member of the Catholic Church.
At one time firms used to paste labels on the bottles in which they
marketed their products. But labels are easily removed. For greater
protection, therefore, enterprising firms got the bottle manufacturers
to mould their name into the very glass, making it part of the bottle.
Then it could never be removed so long as the vessel itself continued
Its rather like that with baptism. Once a Catholic, always a Catholic.
However we may forget, however far we wander, we are still Catholics.
Were a Catholic to die and be brought back to life again, he could not
be re-baptized. He is still what he always was - a Catholic. Even the
taunt, uttered in bitter hatred and anger - I have heard it - "You're a
Catholic and you'll never be anything else," is but expressing the
Of course there is a difference between "being" a Catholic and "living"
as a Catholic. By our baptism we become simply Catholics; not good
ones; not bad ones. Once baptized we are all equally Catholics. But the
kind of Catholic each one is, good, bad, or indifferent, will be
determined by the way in which each one lives. That's why Catholics
vary so greatly in quality. By physical birth we became children of our
natural parents. But that did not compel us to become what our parents
would have wished us to become. So by baptismal re-birth we became
children of God. But that also could not compel us to become what God
wanted us to become. We have free-will, that we may make of ourselves
and of our baptismal inheritance what we choose. However, of that we
shall see more later.
One thing we do know. If we are Catholics, whatever we ourselves are
making of our religion in practice, ours is the best of all religions
on the face of the earth. "Yes. I'm a Catholic; but not much of a one,
so don't judge the Catholic religion by me!" How often that has been
The truth is that the Catholic religion is the most perfectly balanced
and beautiful religion the world has ever seen; the religion given by
God for the eternal salvation of mankind; the religion which history
shows to have been the greatest of all influences for good through the
twenty centuries of our civilization; the religion in which millions
have found peace of soul, and which the saints of every age declare
with one voice to have been the secret of the heroic lives all the
world has been compelled to admire.
I'm not saying that because I happen to be a Catholic. Others who are
not Catholics have paid their tributes to the beauty and power of
Catholicism. Writing in the "Hibbert
Journal," of July, 1930, the Rev. Lloyd Thomas, a Protestant
minister of Birmingham, England, said, "We can all be magnanimous
enough to recognize that Rome is the steward of the moral witness of
the Christian Church. The supreme attraction of Rome is to be found in
its ethical rigorism. She represents the last loyalty of the human race
to its own highest moral standards. She is the steel barrier of
Christianity against the overwhelming invasion of the corrupting
neo-paganism of our times."
I had lunch recently with a prominent Freemason, the Grand Master of
his Lodge, who said to me, "I know you're right, old chap, and I'll
probably become a Catholic some day. But not yet." However he was not
lost to all sense of justice. And at the lunch I have mentioned he told
me of this incident.
"I was talking to a fellow Mason one day," he said, "when he began to
voice his objections to the Catholic Church, declaring that he could.
not stand her intolerance."
"I dislike the Catholic Church for the same reason as yourself," I said
"Do you know why we dislike her so much?"
"Why?" he asked.
"Because," I answered, "she tells us we mustn't do the wrong things we
want to do. Let's get the record straight. No one ever leaves the
Catholic Church in order to become better. And if a man drops his
Catholic religion because it forbids his own
rotten conduct it is because he himself is no good, not because there's
anything wrong with his religion. I have never known anyone to
abandon the Catholic religion and be the better for doing so, whilst no
one has ever sincerely become a Catholic except for higher ideals than
he had before. And if we can't bring ourselves to admit that, we can at
least have the grace to be silent on the subject."
My friend's fellow Mason did not pursue the conversation. But it is not
difficult to understand the impression non-Catholics have of the
intolerance of the Catholic Church. If they haven't the Catholic Faith,
what else are they to think? Take the position.
The Catholic Church knows that she is unique, the one
divinely-authorized custodian of the Truth revealed by God in Jesus
Christ. People are shocked by her claim to be the one true Church; but
she makes that claim - she is the only one that does - and she is ready
to prove it by the evidence of Sacred Scripture, of history, and of
reason. Logically, she makes equally uncompromising claims upon the
lives of her members. She demands that, as men went from God in the
first place by disobedience, so they will retrace their steps by
obedience. If religion is to get us back to God, that must be the very
essence of religion. It was certainly the very essence of the life of
Christ Himself whose motto had been written in advance, "Behold I come
to do Your Will, O God."
It is this Catholic religion which has been, and is, to millions of
people the light of their minds and the pledge of their salvation. For
Catholic worship is all to one purpose - to make us better, to unite us
to God, to console and strengthen us in the trials of life, to ensure
our happiness in heaven. Its the only philosophy worth while - religion
perfecting the complete human being, body and soul, mind and heart, for
time and eternity.
That is the religion to. which all baptized; Catholics belong, the
missing ones as well as those who have refused to drift.
The missing ones; who have never known any other religion than that of
their baptism, and who perhaps know very little beyond the fact that
they ought to be Catholics, owe even that much to the heroic and
unswerving fidelity of a long line of Catholics before them. For if you
are one of the missing Catholics today, you are at least a descendant
of those who kept the Faith in the past, often enduring incredible
sufferings and privations rather than forsake it. There are also many
non-Catholics who are the descendants of those who abandoned their
religion under the stress of persecution. That story, of course, could
lead us a long way back.
The early Christians, during the first three hundred years when it was
death to be a Catholic, braved all penalties and took all risks rather
than desert the same Faith as that which we profess.
Nearer to hand is the Protestant Reformation period. In the face of the
most violent measures of repression, confiscation of property, and
threats to their lives, nations like Ireland and Poland, large sections
of Germany and Holland, though only a handful, alas, in England and
Scotland, remained true to their Catholic inheritance. Their fidelity
to their religion did not mean less loyalty to their country,
generosity and devotedness in its service, and courage in its defence.
But they had a loyalty to God and to their conscience which they were
determined also to maintain; and the faith of succeeding generations of
Catholics was a legacy made possible by their fidelity.
I am very conscious, as a convert, when speaking to those whose
forefathers remained true to the Faith, that I myself am a descendant
of those who deserted it. Who is the son of renegades, that he should
urge the children of the martyrs to stand firm? Yet I do not often
presume to do that. This particular booklet is quite exceptional. For
my life-work has been almost invariably directed towards those still in
the ranks of those from whom I came, the ranks of those born of
non-Catholic parents and who, through no fault of their own, have
neither known Catholicism nor dreamed that there they might find the
For over a quarter of a century now my main duty has been that of
replying by radio to inquiries about the Catholic religion submitted by
the general public. And that, of course, ties one down to the isolated
and disconnected problems each listener wants to hear discussed.
However, I have also been able to undertake many missions to
non-Catholics when a much more comprehensive presentation of the
Catholic religion has been possible.
It is in such missions above all that one can enkindle a hunger for
Catholicism in the hearts of those who have never known it, a new
desire which gives them no peace until they too possess this greatest
of all God's blessings to mankind. Catholics attending such missions
have benefited greatly from them. How many of them have said, "Father,
I have learned more about my religion hearing it explained to others
than I ever knew before!" But such missions are not primarily for them.
They are for the "other sheep" whom Our Lord wills also to be brought
into the one fold of the Catholic Church. And hundreds of converts have
resulted from them. As one of them put it, "I went away feeling that I
was missing ever so much by not being a Catholic!"
To instruct and receive converts into the Church is a source of
perpetual edification, and often of astonishment. They come so humbly,
"Father, I don't know what I have ever done to deserve so great a grace
as this," one will say. Or again, "I don't know how I lived all those
years without being a Catholic." Or another, "Now I must set to work
and make up for lost time. I'll never overtake your good Catholics who
have had the Faith since childhood and have been able to receive Holy
Communion all their lives!"
These converts firmly believe they have discovered a joy which has been
the life-long experience of the born Catholic; as it could and should
be, were every Catholic to take his religion seriously. Read what some
of them have had to say!
"Every hour," wrote Frederick William Faber, "so augments inward peace
that I cannot but yearn that those I love should enjoy the same
privileges with myself. A new light seems to be shed on everything - a
light so clear as to surprise me."
"From the time I became a Catholic," Cardinal Newman wrote in his turn,
"I have been in perfect peace and contentment. It was like coming into
port after a rough sea."
Father Maturin said, of his own experience, "There has been an
ever-deepening sense of security, with moments of intense realization
of the glory and strength of the City of God, whose walls are salvation
and whose gates are peace."
"The Church promises a great deal," exclaimed Robert Hugh Benson, "but
my experience is that she gives ten times more. The Catholic Church is
supremely what she promises to be. She is the priceless pearl for which
the greatest sacrifice is not too great."
"The Church is fairer than we dared to dream," declared Kegan Paul,
"and my first fervour was as nothing to what I feel now. Day by day the
mystery of the Altar seems greater, the unseen world nearer, God more a
Father, Our Lady more tender, the great company of the Saints more
friendly, my Guardian Angel closer to my side."
"No sacrifice is too great," said Benson. Thousands of converts have
had that conviction. I have seen staggering sacrifices made by converts
I myself have received into the Church; relatives alienated, friends
lost, legacies forfeited, business prospects ruined. With St. Paul, as
Monsignor Knox gives us his words, they have said, "There is nothing I
do not write down as loss compared with the high privilege of knowing
Christ Jesus, my Lord. For love of Him I have lost everything, treat
everything else as refuse, if I may have Christ to my credit." (Phil,
How many times I have said to careless Catholics, "If you had had to
make anything like the sacrifices to keep your faith which so many
converts have made to become a Catholic, you would not throw your
religion away as though it were worthless! But you have not appreciated
it, you have just taken it for granted, because you got it too easily,
So often they are those who have been without it who know how to make
the best use of it when they get it. But surely everyone bearing the
Catholic name would agree that it shouldn't be so, and that those who
have had the Faith all their lives should be the ones who have grown
into the greater appreciation of it!
The enemies of the Catholic Church certainly do not take her cheaply!
They are not indifferent to her, and wanting in enthusiasm in their
efforts to bring about her destruction. Throughout the world atheists,
secularists, and communists wage continual war against her. Communists,
of course, wherever they are in power have come right out into the open.
A Catholic girl, recently escaped  from Hungary, tells how she
went to church one Sunday morning in her entirely Catholic village.
But, with all the other Catholics arriving for Mass, she found the
doors of the building closed, a Communist guard lined up to prevent the
people from entering, and on the door of the church a great placard:
"THIS CHURCH IS CLOSED - BECAUSE THERE IS NO GOD."
But in our own democracies, secularists, unbelieving materialists, are
no less active. In season and out of season, in books, newspapers, and
from public platforms, they seek to undermine Christian principles and
practices, concentrating their attention on the Catholic Church which
they instinctively recognize as the last stronghold of the Christian
religion in this world.
Theirs is the new paganism with which Catholics have to contend, as the
early Christians had to contend with the paganism of the ancient Roman
world. It is not a conflict between morality and immorality - a
conflict with people accepting Christian teaching but not living up to
it. It is a conflict between two different moralities, secular and
Christian. The one holds that man is but an animal, with no future
beyond this life, and no obligation to live as if he were not a mere
animal. The other holds that man is a child of God consisting of a body
and of a soul made in God's image and likeness, a soul immortal of its
very nature and destined to live on forever in a state of eternal
happiness or eternal misery according to the way in which he has
behaved during his time of probation on earth.
But the fight against the sheer and dreary, yet very militant
irreligion of the secularists is not the only battle to be fought.
Unfortunately, sympathizing with the attack upon the Catholic Church by
complete unbelievers, religious prejudice and bigotry have joined
forces with them. If ever people knew not what they were doing, they
are those non-Catholics who, whilst professing to be Christians, seek
in every way to discredit and destroy the Catholic Church. For if she
goes, their churches go also.
What can one say of them? Is their hatred of the Catholic religion so
much greater than their love for Christ that they are willing to become
friends with the enemies of all religion in the hope of wrecking the
Catholic Church? Inevitably one thinks of Herod and Pilate, who became
friends as Christ Himself went to His death!
After his conversion, G. K. Chesterton wrote a book on the things that
would have made him a Catholic, if he had not already become one.
Certainly the diabolical hatred of the Catholic Church, whether on the
part of secularist unbelievers or of those who are the victims of
unreasoning religious prejudice and blind bigotry, would have been
sufficient to make me suspect the truth of the Catholic Church had I
myself not been moved by other considerations to become a Catholic.
In the early Church many converts from paganism owed their conversion
to the very sight of the violent and irrational hatred for the name of
Christ. They were led to study His life and claims. They found that He
was goodness itself, and incapable of speaking anything but the truth.
Only the rebellious principle of evil which abominates God could
explain the infernal hatred of which He was the object. They were
shocked into taking sides. And being men of good-will, on the side of
decency and virtue, they felt that they had no choice but to become
The same thing is happening today. There are those who have seen that
the same forces which have given rise to a hatred of Christ through all
the ages are directed in a peculiar way against the Catholic Church as
against no other institution in this world. This phenomenon has started
them on their enquiries. And they have ended by becoming Catholics.
MAN WHO CAME BACK
But not only non-Catholics have reacted in such a way. Many a careless
Catholic has been driven back to the fervent practice of his religion
by a sudden advertence to the issues at stake.
I remember the case of one Catholic man, a railway employee, who had
been transferred away from home to a country centre as a machinist
fitter in the railway depot workshop there. In his new surroundings he
dropped his religion in practice, neither making himself known to the
local priest, nor attending Mass. None of his fellow workers was so
much as aware that he was a Catholic. No letters of mine, written to
him at the request of his parents, seemed to have any effect upon him.
One day, however, during the lunch hour, the Catholic Church came up
for discussion; and such a tirade of abuse against Catholics and their
religion, such a stream of vile calumnies against priests and nuns,
poured from the lips of one of the men, that the Catholic was shocked
out of his lethargy and indifference. He told the offender what he
thought of him. He told the others what lying calumnies they had just
heard. He professed himself to be a Catholic - a bad one till then, but
not henceforth. The next week-end saw him at confession and Mass and
Holy Communion. And he has never looked back.
"In that moment," he wrote to me, "I was made to realize that I was
either a Catholic or a traitor; as much an enemy of the Church as any
other - even worse. I had to take sides, and I wasn't going to be one
of that crew. So I've returned to the Sacraments - to stay. I've had my
We Catholics have a responsibility. To us has been entrusted the
interests of the Kingdom of God on earth, in the face of a world hatred
of us Christ predicted and in spite of the opposition of even
religiously-minded people misguided enough to think they do God a
service by hindering us in every possible way.
We can't get away from that responsibility. We have been baptized as
Catholics. Just as we have been born into human society and must accept
our social duties, so we have been born into that great spiritual
society known as the Catholic Church by a supernatural re-birth, and
must accept the duties proper to that society also. We walk in two
societies, the nation and the Church, with two sets of duties to be
It was an infidel who said, "Did I firmly believe, as millions say they
do, that the knowledge and practice of religion in this life influences
destiny in another, religion would be to me everything. It would be my
first waking thought, and my last image before sleep sank me into
unconsciousness. I would strive to look upon eternity alone, and on the
immortal souls around me, soon to be everlastingly miserable or
Certainly if the Catholic Church is to do her work the first thing
necessary is for her own members to equip themselves and stand firm.
The Church desperately needs Catholics who take their religion
seriously, and who are militant in their fight against unchristian and
antichristian influences, zealous in their positive efforts to observe
Christian principles in their personal conduct, and to diffuse them in
the home circle, in commercial, professional and national life.
"The Barque of Peter," said an old sea-captain who happened to be an
excellent Catholic, "is no tourist ship, but a freighter. She has no
room for passengers; only crew. And its a case of all hands on deck."
The "love of Christ urges us," said St. Paul. By His goodness to us, He
has placed us under an enormous obligation which it is for us to try to
realize - and to repay.
No one could pretend for a moment, of course, that all Catholics even
attempt to fulfil their obligation. I commenced this booklet by
speaking of the "missing" Catholics. They, alas, are legion. In all our
big cities, and scattered up and down the country, are hosts of
Catholics known to be such only by themselves - and God. They are
missing from their Church, unacquainted with their priest, unrecorded
in diocesan statistics.
What are the causes of this tragedy? To put the question directly to
missing Catholics, why have you drifted away from the practice of your
There is, I know, the paralysing influence of the secular environment
in which we live. The external changes in the world are as nothing
compared with the change that has come over men's souls.
We live in a world of "shaking foundations and dissolving loyalties."
Secularism has swept through the ranks of the society in which we live
and move and have our very being. National and international
authorities ignore religion. Books, newspapers, films - all conspire to
promote the struggle for and enjoyment of material welfare to the
forgetfulness of God. The wave of popular indifference to religion
creates the impression that destiny doesn't really depend on religious
considerations; that they are not essential; that one can take them or
leave them as one pleases.
Well, its easier, undoubtedly, to go with the current than swim against
it. But to deplore the moral and spiritual breakdown of our
civilization - as so many even amongst the missing Catholics do - and
also forsake the practice of one's religion is surely no way to make
It may take an effort; but the only thing to do is to turn and swim
against the tide sweeping so relentlessly on towards the abyss of
irreligion and despair.
"But I don't know anything about my religion" has often been said by
I must confess that I have never heard that plea without a good deal of
sympathy for those who make it. There are thousands of people in this
country whose parents had enough faith to get them baptized, but not
enough faith to bother teaching them their religion. And to be sent to
state schools where religion was expressly excluded from the subjects
taught did not help, to say the least. So it can easily be that many a
Catholic has left school and set out on life with little or no real
knowledge of his religion, and still less training in its duties.
But such a boy or girl still remains a Catholic. And there is no reason
why one's lack of knowledge of religion should not be made good in
later years. We try to improve our knowledge of ever so many things
inadequately taught us at school. Why take it for granted that a
child's knowledge - such as it is - should be enough to see us through
life where our religion is concerned?
Surely the effort to remedy ignorance of our religion would be well
worth while. A Catholic boy, after many years of study to fit himself
for the priesthood, leaves home and country to go to the foreign
missions. There he has to set to work to learn a new and difficult
language. Then, in a climate that is bad, and fever rampant, with
barely the necessaries of life provided for him, certainly with no
worldly advantages, he devotes all his energies to spreading a
knowledge of the Catholic Faith amongst pagan tribes. If he is prepared
to endure such self-sacrifice that others may obtain a knowledge of the
Catholic religion, should not ill-instructed Catholics at home go to
the much less trouble of securing a sound knowledge of it for
Or take another case. A young and good-hearted Protestant lad, of about
eighteen years of age, met a blind Catholic man and offered to visit
him occasionally in order to read to him. One day the blind man wanted
a pamphlet about the Catholic religion read to him. So impressed was
the Protestant good Samaritan by the contents of that one booklet, that
he obtained and read for himself every Catholic booklet he could lay
hands upon. He sought instruction from a priest, was received into the
Church, and went on with his studies until there were few Catholic
laymen who had anything like his knowledge of their religion. They
envied him his knowledge, his fervour, and his enthusiasm for it. But
it did not seem to enter their heads that they could become equally
proficient in their religion did they take the same interest in it.
Why should not the born Catholic re-study his religion in his adult
years, with the greater understanding of it which is then possible,
just as every convert has had to study it? I have even heard Catholics
say wistfully that converts make the best Catholics. But there is no
earthly reason why that should be so; and it would not be so - if it is
so - had all Catholics made the same efforts to know and understand
their religion as converts in their efforts to get it.
THAT'S WHAT RELIGION MEANS!"
There are, of course, many reasons given by missing Catholics for their
neglect of religious duties. But we all know, even as they themselves -
in their heart of hearts - know the answer to them.
For example, there are those who point to the poor lives and the bad
example given by many who regularly attend church and fulfil their
religious obligations of worship. And they will say, "If that's what
religion means, I don't want it." But they know quite well that that's
not what the Catholic religion means.
During the years before I became a Catholic I had often said that
Catholics are a pretty poor lot in practice, and that the history of
their Church is a quarry from which scandals can be unearthed almost at
will. And I still say it, though now without losing sight of the other
side of the picture.
One who knows the teaching of Christ and the proverbial weakness of
human nature soon gets over the shock of dis-edifying lives. It was
Christ Himself who said, "It must needs be that scandals will come."
But He did not forget to add, "Nevertheless, woe to that man by whom
the scandal comes." Not for a moment would He sanction the scandals.
Nor does the Catholic Church. However gentle she may be towards
sinners, she is adamant in condemning the sin. Meantime, she knows what
the Catholic religion can do in the Saints. Where that religion fails
to secure such results, it has been held in check by the evil
propensities or the human frailties of those who have resisted its
But how unfair is the attitude of those who make the faults of others
an excuse for their own laxity should be evident. No man refuses to
join even a political party because he happens to like or not like
someone who belongs to it instead of examining the party's programme.
Let us take the Catholic religion as it is in itself. On the twentieth
anniversary of his reception into the Church, Monsignor Ronald Knox
answered the question as to whether he was disappointed with the
Catholic Church after having made its closer acquaintance. And his
reply went something like this: "Am I disappointed? With myself, yes;
for when I was received into the Church it seemed that there was
nothing left for me now but to become a saint, and I'm far from that
yet. With Catholics, yes; for they are not half as good as they ought
to be with so wonderful a religion; with priests, yes; even as they are
all disappointed with themselves. With the Catholic Church, no; she is
the one true Church she has ever claimed to be."
Missing Catholics ought to ask themselves, in turn, some questions. If
the reality at times does not seem to correspond with the ideal, are
things improved by our abandoning the Church also, and helping to make
the contrast still more glaring? And whom does one hurt by the neglect
of one's own religious duties? Not those of whose conduct we complain.
Their sins are not remedied by our sinning too. They are not converted
by our sharing in their infidelity. The only ones we hurt are Our Lord,
our own souls, and all whom our own bad example helps to lead astray.
The wrong ones are being punished - and fruitlessly!
One excuse not uncommonly heard is: "I don't attend church any more,
because the priests are always asking for money."
Well, for whom do they ask it? For themselves? Or for the poor, for our
children in the schools, for foreign missions, for works of charity,
for the glory of God's House? They have to let us know what is needed,
for that is their responsibility. But if we give of the possessions our
life makes possible, the priest gives still more, himself, his life,
renouncing an earthly career and family affections. Moreover, everyone
knows that no Catholic is asked to give more than he can afford.
But if there were anything in this excuse, it would be as valid for
good Catholics as for the careless ones; and the good ones have never
made this charge a reason for neglecting fidelity in their religious
duties to God. In a spirit of deep faith and with spontaneous
generosity they have delighted in supporting their Church.
"I've never been the poorer for giving to God, Father," said an old
Catholic working man to me one day, "and I've certainly never yet heard
of anyone going bankrupt through doing so."
There is something in casting your bread upon the waters!
To the credit of most missing Catholics it must be said that they
refuse to fall back on the shortcomings of others as an excuse for
their own neglect. More often they will say, "What's the use of going
to church? I can't live up to it, and I'm not going to be a hypocrite
and pretend I do." One has at least to admire the honesty and humility
of the admission that the fault lies in oneself.
But to go to Mass is not to pretend to be a saint! Nor need there be a
trace of hypocrisy in such an external fulfilment of religious duties.
The Pharisee may have been a hypocrite, but the publican wasn't; though
both equally went into the Temple - "the publican to pray," as St.
Augustine remarks, "the Pharisee to praise - himself!"
I know what you will say, "The publican was repentant and didn't intend
to go on with his sins; and I can't break with mine." Even so, you
would not necessarily be a hypocrite by continuing to attend Mass.
Hypocrisy depends on one's motive. If you did go to Mass in order to
pretend that you were good, you would be a hypocrite; but not if you
went without any such pretence, moved only by the desire to fulfil
God's law as far as you could.
The Catholic Church has always refused to become the Church of the
"elect." Arnold Lunn remarks somewhere that if a Methodist keeps a
mistress he ceases to attend his Church; but a Catholic in a similar
position would still go to Mass even though unable to approach the
Sacraments. He knows that the Catholic Church is for all, sinners as
well as saints.
The Catholic Church never forgets her Divine Founder's words, "I come
to call, not the just who need not repentance, but sinners." So she
bids sinners come, not because they are good, but because they should
want to be good, and because she knows how to deal with their sins. If
they don't become good quickly enough, and she is reproached for the
low standards of so many who frequent her services, she has her answer
in the legion of saints through all the ages.
I remember an old priest going round his parish taking the census. He
came to the house of a man who at first denied that he was a Catholic.
But the man didn't do it too convincingly and the priest pressed the
question as to his religion.
"Well, Father," the man said, "if you must know, I'm a Catholic - or
supposed to be one. But you may as well wipe me off. I'm no good."
The old priest's eyes softened at once. "For that matter, I'm not much
good myself," he said, "but if we can't do what we can't do, that's no
reason why we shouldn't do what we can do. I'm trying to do what I can
do, and that's why I'm looking you up. And you can at least come to
Mass, even if you can't do everything else. And you can say your
prayers. You know, if you break one commandment, that's no reason why
you should break the lot. There's no point in telling God that you
might as well be hanged for a sheep as for a lamb. Be as generous as
you can with God, and He'll find a way to be generous to you in the
end, believe me."
The man believed him, and went regularly to Mass after that; and the
day came when he made his peace with God, returned to the Sacraments,
and more than experienced the generosity of God upon which the old
priest had promised him he could rely.
Does the fulfilment of our religious duties matter? Of course it
matters! More than anything else.
What we do about it is the most important fact in our human existence.
Our religious duties are the most valuable of all the things we do. For
they alone enable us to transcend an ignoble self-love; and upon our
acceptance or rejection of them our very eternity depends.
A man may sin through human frailty in other ways - a frailty for which
God is prepared to make every possible allowance. But the omission of
religious duties is a cold, calculating form of injustice which can
make no claim to such consideration. And if, as Holy Scripture says,
the very pagans were guilty because they did not worship God as they
should; if the Jews were guilty - guilty to the extent of forfeiting
their inheritance; how much more guilty are Catholics who today claim
that inheritance as their own, yet neglect the greatest of its
obligations - to render due and fitting worship to God?
It is not that God needs our worship. But not to render that worship is
the greatest possible injustice on our part; and God cannot want us to
be unjust. If we pay butcher and baker and grocer for the food by which
we maintain life, how much more ready we should be to make a due return
to God for the life that food maintains?
Religion is the highest form of justice, inspiring us to render due
acknowledgement to God. That is why, in giving us the ten commandments
in the right order of importance, God Himself devoted the first three
of them to our obligations towards Himself. He insists that we
acknowledge Him to be the one and only True God! that we hold Him in
due reverence; and that we regularly fulfil our duties of religious
To have no religion, then is a very evil thing, the greatest of all
dishonesties. And is it not a striking fact that even irreligious
parents would not take from their own children what they expect God to
take from them? What parents would permit their children to ignore them
completely and treat them as if they did not so much as exist?
CAUSE OF CHRIST
Look again at what our religion means. After all, we are Christians. We
believe that "God so loved the world as to give His only -begotten
Son." "Man,"' said St. Augustine, "owed God so great a debt that he
could not pay; therefore God became man and as man paid man's debt." It
meant a life of suffering; ending in His death. It seems almost
incredible that any Catholic could believe that the Eternal Son of God
went to so much trouble on our behalf, yet not even go to the trouble
of taking his religion seriously.
Remember who Christ is. You have but to grant a single point - that He
was not the greatest liar and blasphemer who ever set foot in this
world. For, if not, then He was what He claimed to be - God; and all
that He declares will happen is going to happen. He will come to judge
the living and the dead.
To His Church we Catholics belong. And that Church is not merely a
mechanical machine of cogs running under a single central motor. She is
a living organism, of which we are the living cells, every cell
contributing to her health and vitality.
But there are degrees of life, spiritually as well as physically. After
the last war, Europe was swarming with orphaned and vagabond children,
living by scavenging. But they were only just alive, poor, thin,
emaciated, under-nourished, with no glow of health, no vigour of life.
Spiritually, also, there are Catholics like that, with no glow of
fervour, no desire of virtue, no taste for the things of God, no
longing for heaven. They are spiritually ill, half-dead.
Well, God has given us the Faith; but He won't compel us to live it.
And no one else can live our lives for us. It is for each one of us to
do his part. And how necessary it is that each should do so! True, the
Catholic Church cannot die. Our Lord has promised that. But she can
lose power as life and vitality fail in any one of us. She can be
weaker when slothful and careless Catholics abound.
The cause of Christ is, then, the cause of every Catholic without
exception. Every missing Catholic lets Him down and weakens the Church.
The missing Catholic may ask, "But where shall I begin?"
To that I would say, "At least begin
by taking up the duty of prayer." It may need an effort at
first, because you have got out of the habit of it. But you will grow
into it. We learn to pray by praying, as a child learns to walk by
walking. If you have forgotten your prayers, get a prayer-book.
One thing is certain. Prayer is absolutely necessary. God has made the
welfare of our soul depend upon it, even as He has made our bodily life
dependent upon the air we breathe. "Alas for the man too busy to pray,"
exclaimed Cardinal Manning, "for he is too busy to save his soul."
Christ Himself both set us the example of prayer and taught us the
necessity of it. Whatever else He Himself did, He prayed. "Rising
early, He went to a desert place and there He prayed." "He ascended
into a mountain alone to pray." He spent "the whole night in prayer."
"Being in an agony, He prayed the longer." And to us He says, "Watch
and pray." "Ask and you shall receive."
Secondly, if you do not
already go, resume your attendance
at Mass at least on Sundays and Holy Days of obligation. The
fulfilment of the religious duty of assistance at the public and
corporate worship of God in our churches is essential. It is by such
attendance that we publicly acknowledge the duty of religion, publicly
profess our belief as Catholics, make public admission of the need of
God's help. To neglect Mass is to give our vote that God shall be
The mystery is that any Catholic can bring himself to miss Mass. We
know the price our Catholic ancestors paid rather than allow themselves
to be robbed of it. At the time of the Protestant Reformation in
England, St. John Fisher, Bishop of Rochester, challenged Cranmer with
the protest, "He who would abolish the Mass plots no less a calamity
than would be the destruction of the very sun from the heavens."
Even a non-Catholic of our own times, Augustine Birrell, wrote in the "Nineteenth Century" magazine,
"Nobody nowadays, save a handful of vulgar fanatics speaks irreverently
of the Mass. If indeed the Incarnation be the one divine event to which
the whole creation moves, the miracle of the Altar may well see its
restful shadow cast over a dry and thirsty land for the help of man. .
. . It is the Mass that matters; it is the Mass that makes the
Thirdly, let us read all we can about our Faith,
and improve our knowledge of it. And let us do our best to live up to
its ideals in our personal daily lives. In that, of course, we shall be
only more or less successful. We are not saints. We have our human
frailties. But we must try. As the old priest I have mentioned earlier
said, "If we can't do what we can't do, we can do what we can do," and
if we are faithful to our personal prayers and to our assistance at
Mass, these religious practices will gradually emancipate us from
slavish subjection to temporal and passing material things, help us to
recover our sense of true values, and let into our lives the light of
WORLD NOT ALL
The more we think, the more we see the necessity of this recovery of
our sense of true values.
It may be that our civilization will perish unless people turn to God.
But the real reason for a return to God is that He wants us and we need
Him. In Him alone will we find a purpose great enough to satisfy the
innate longings which are part of our very nature. Man lives by bread,
but not by bread alone. He hungers for faith and hope and love. And his
faith must be faith in something, in someone.
Communists speak of the Christian hope as "Pie in the sky when you
die." But everyone knows that to be a caricature; that it's not "pie,"
nor in the "sky," that awaits us. However, there are many who are not
Communists, yet who refuse to look beyond this life at all. "Give me
enough to eat and drink, a decent home, and a wife or husband as the
case may be, and a certain amount of enjoyment, and that's all I ask of
But that's all an animal asks - food, shelter, a mate, and a bit of
play when young. And we are not mere animals. The man who lives like
that may say, "Well, I'm happy;" but he is not half as happy as he is
meant to be. He is neither putting into life nor getting out of it
anything like what he could. He is missing the real meaning and
direction of life, and will end having had no serious purpose, having
done no particular good, and having a judgement to face for having
rejected the one hope of his salvation.
THEN THE JUDGEMENT
The eternal truths are realities, whatever we choose to do about them.
Thus all admit that death comes to everybody, and that they too must
die. But many refuse to believe this in practice and behave as if they
were going to live forever and never die. Yet the shadow of death is
always there; and the dread of what lies beyond it is never really
lifted from us, however little we can bear to think about it.
So, too, the great facts of the Incarnation and of the Catholic Church
remain the same, whether we take notice of them or not. But to behave
as if the Incarnation had never happened, and as if Our Lord had never
gone to the trouble of establishing His Church at all; to behave as if
these things had nothing whatever to do with you, is a very great sin.
"When the Holy Ghost is come," Our Lord said, "He will convince the
world of sin, because they believed not in Me." It is true that people
whose eyes are dim to God are little concerned about their sins.
Conscience can be repressed so that its voice is scarcely heard. People
can even pretend to themselves that what is wrong is right, when they
wish to do it. But God's law is still there, and is still what it is.
Can we help asking ourselves whether God is satisfied with us, and
whether it matters whether He is or not? He is going to ask us some day
what we have made of our religion; what our religion has meant to us,
and we to it. And there is a judgement, with a possible sentence of
eternal condemnation. If you say, "I don't worry about the next world,"
then spare yourself having to worry about it when you're in it. Use
this life as a preparation for it - a brief period during which you are
free to ensure for yourself eternal happiness, instead of the loss of
it and all that that will mean.
Every Catholic - even the missing Catholic - finds himself thinking at
times along these lines. For things happen that bring home to him the
fact that his faith is not dead yet.
A young garage hand, who had been coming to me for instructions during
several months, on hearing that I was to go away to a distant place for
quite a time, begged me to receive him into the Church before I went.
The only opportunity was on the following Tuesday morning, which would
mean his being late on the job that day.
"I'll manage it, Father," he said, "The boss isn't a Catholic, and
we're very busy, but I think I'll be able to get around him."
The lad turned up at the appointed time and was duly received into the
Church. Afterwards I said to him, "The boss didn't mind?" "Not in the
end," he said. "But when I first mentioned it to him, he just exploded.
Literally shouted that we were behind with everything, that he wasn't
going to have any slackers hanging around his shop, and that he
wouldn't hear of it. When I could get a word in, I told him that I was
going to become a Catholic, that the priest was going away, and the
only chance he had to receive me into the Church was this morning. You
should have seen the change that came over him. He stopped as if
somebody had hit him on the head with a hammer. Then he put out his
hand and said, 'God bless you, Bob. You can have a week off for that if
you need it. I only hope you'll be a better Catholic than I am.' Then
he just turned away and left me breathless. No one in the place had
ever guessed that he was a Catholic. It's wonderful where they turn up,
Father, when you come to think of it!"
That boss was a typical missing Catholic: faith enough to be happy in
the thought of others becoming Catholics, yet not conviction enough to
live up to his religion himself. Or maybe there was nothing wrong with
his convictions. He had just drifted away, still hoping that all would
come right in the end - a hope very near to presumption, ever liable to
fall into the other extreme of despair.
Cardinal Manning has well described such types. "Men are ever beguiling
themselves," he writes, "with a dream that they shall be what they are
not now; they hope one day to be different; they balance their present
consciousness of a low worldly life, and of a mind heavy and dull to
spiritual things, with the lazy thought that some day God will bring
home to them in power the realities of faith in Christ. So men dream
away their lives in pleasure, sloth, trade or study. Who is there that
has not at some time secretly indulged this soothing flattering, that
the staid gravity of age, when youth is quelled; or the leisure of
retirement, when the fret of busy life is over; or, it may be, the
inevitable pains and griefs which are man's inheritance, shall one day
break up in his heart the now sealed fountain of repentance and make at
last his religion a reality? Who has not allayed the uneasy
consciousness of a meagre religion with the hope of a future change?
Who has not been mocked by the enemy of mankind, the enemy of every
man? Who has not listened, all too readily to him who would cheat us of
the hour that is, and of the spiritual earnings which faith makes day
by day in God's service, stealing from us the present hour that is, and
leaving us a lie in exchange?"
How well I remember being called to the death-bed of a military officer
who had abandoned the Protestantism of his youth for a life of complete
irreligion! In his last lingering illness from cancer of the lungs and
throat, due to his having been gassed during the first World War, he
had taken up the study of the Catholic religion. As a result he asked
to be received into the Catholic Church. But the new realization of the
things that really matter drew from him the remark, "Well, Father, I'm
saving my soul, but I've lost my life. That life I used for myself as
long as it was any good to me. But now it's of no use any more, I'm
giving God the dregs. I wish to God I had been a Catholic as a boy.
Things would have been very different then."
Surely the only sensible choice is to take up our religion and to make
the most of it whilst the opportunity is ours.
We are living in the midst of a serious emergency, a time of economic
and social troubles both national and international. And there are
those who say that these anxieties are more than enough to occupy their
thoughts - that it will be time enough to think about religion when
things get better. But what made the emergency? Not the things we see.
Evil dispositions in the souls of men have been the main cause of all
the troubles. And the problems will be there until we put our souls
right - which can only be when our souls are right with God.
How to go about that, we Catholics know. The Catholic Church still
lives, and is the one true Church. She is the Church of the centuries,
from which the Western nations departed with anything but a blessing to
themselves, and in drifting from which no individual Catholic has yet
found true happiness.
Faith in his religion, attendance at Mass, reception of the Sacraments,
personal prayer, efforts to live up to the commandments of God and to
the precepts of the Church - these are the things that alone can give
happiness to the soul of the Catholic; and even in this life, not to
speak of the next.
So we come to the end of this little book, in the writing of which I
myself have been a prey to many varied sentiments in turn.
For a Catholic cannot dwell on the thought of the Catholic Church to
which he belongs without pride in all that she is in herself,
indignation that her enemies should utter such vile calumnies against
her and seek only to do her injury, a renewed love for the high ideals
she ever puts before him, shame and a sense of guilt that in his own
life he should fall so far short of them, and a wistful longing for
those loftier standards in practice which his better-self cannot but
And is there a missing Catholic who has read these pages unmoved in any
or all of these ways? I do not believe it. I have mentioned the taunt:
"You're a Catholic, and you'll never be anything else." That is true;
though it is not an insult, as bitterly prejudiced people imagine, but
a compliment. We appreciate it as such. But can one be a Catholic, and
not respond to all that has been said in this little book?
Then, I would say, for the love of God, do something about it.
Determine to improve your knowledge of your religion. Read all you can
find on that subject. We all need to do that, for the teachings of our
religion will not remain automatically alive in our memories. We need
constantly to remind ourselves of them. Take up your prayers and your
regular attendance at Mass. Go to see ,our priest, and if there are any
obstacles in your way, talk them over with him. He will explain ways
and means. They may be much smoother and easier than you at present
imagine. And the happiness awaiting you will be beyond all the
expectations with which you set out on your new programme of life as a
* * *